UEHP  
  26th October 2018  
 
European Forum Gastein 2018: Economics matters!
During the last edition of the European Health Forum in Gastein, interesting questions were debated. One plenary session was specifically dedicated to investment. We know that strategic investments in health are required but shouldn´t we also discuss return on invested capital (ROIC)? The first benefit concerns clearly the patient, patient satisfaction with care delivered by attentive health professionals. The second one must be economic adaptation and how to provide quality care at a reasonable cost in all EU Member States while respecting budget limitations. The answer to this complex question is the private sector specificity, limiting unnecessary costs by managing a talented workforce and offering modern treatment solutions. Our challenge is to concretize the framework presented in Gastein, transforming the idea into a reality accessible to all European Citizens.
Dr Paul Garassus
President of UEHP
 
       
 
LATEST NEWS
UEHP-SHAM Master Class
New Generation of Risk Management
UEHP is organising a MASTER CLASS on “NEW GENERATION of RISK MANAGEMENT”, in close partnership with SHAM - Hospital Mutual Insurance Company – European leader in hospital risk.
The Master Class will take place on Tuesday, 20th November, in Brussels at UEHP headquarter (Avenue de la Joyeuse Entrée, 1 B - 1040). 
The agenda of the day is now available HERE !
During this one day session, participants will benefit from a selective panel of experts and counterparts to foster active contribution, interactivity, mutual thinking and share lessons learnt from various experience and concrete actions.
In a context of multi-factor transition faced by European healthcare systems, a new set of complexities arises:
  • new technology implementation,
  • relationship with patients,
  • social networks,
  • regulation according to national laws and European directives.
Those factors are changing equilibrium with potential underlying risks going beyond current resilience. Risk Management offers levers to secure and optimize operations, with the need for an innovative approach to adapt to emerging and evolving risk profiles.
We are targeting Top European Executives (CEO, COO, Risk Manager, Medical, Legal Director) from private hospitals/clinics in all Europe, with a special focus on four leading countries (but not exclusively): France, Germany, Italy and Spain.
Join the debate! On one hand, your experience, knowledge and activity could be a valuable contribution to the discussion. On the other hand, the Master Class will be the occasion for you to learn more about the latest trends on Risk management in Europe, as well as to network with other top European Hospital Managers and discuss about your own experiences, problems and best practices.
Master class’s programme and objectives: Follow this link
For registrations and information: secretarygeneral@uehp.org
 
UEHP
Special thanks to the Polish Association of Private Hospitals
We would like to thank the Polish Association of Private Hospitals, PAPH, Dr Andrzej Sokołowski and Dr Piotr Gerber and the whole PAPH team, for their warmest welcome and outstanding organization during the latest UEHP Council Meeting in Warsaw on September 28. Thank you also to Mr Maciej Milkowski, Undersecretary of State, Polish Ministry of Health, for attending our meeting.
Look back in pictures: View the slideshow
 
UEHP
UEHP accepted as member of the European AI Alliance
The European Commission created the European Artificial Intelligence Alliance, a forum engaged in a broad and open discussion of all aspects of Artificial Intelligence development and its impacts.
The platform encourages broad participation in the policy-making process of the European Commission. Members of the Alliance will be able to engage in discussions with each other and the experts of the Artificial Intelligence High Level Expert Group in a dedicated forum.
Given the scale of the challenge associated with AI, the full mobilisation of a diverse set of participants, including businesses, consumer organisations, trade unions, and other representatives of civil society bodies is essential. The European AI Alliance will form a broad multi-stakeholder platform which will complement and support the work of the AI High Level Expert Group in particular in preparing draft AI ethics guidelines, and ensuring competitiveness of the European Region in the burgeoning field of Artificial Intelligence. The European Commission plans to host its first Annual AI Alliance Conference in 2019. 
We are glad to annonce that UEHP applied for the membership and was accepted!
We look forward starting this new adventure with the full support of our members! 
More information about the platform HERE
 
UEHP
Value Based Healthcare
UEHP involved in the high level discussion on its implementation
On October 18, the International Consortium for Health Outcomes Measurement (ICHOM) in collaboration with EFPIA and pharma.be hosted a full-day seminar in Brussels on how to drive healthcare systems towards becoming more outcomes-based, patient-centred and efficient through the standardised measurement of patient-relevant health outcomes.
Throughout the day, expert presentations guided the participants through the theory and practice behind measuring health outcomes, how ICHOM standard sets in different disease areas are constructed. Participants also heard several practical case-studies on how the consistent measurement of outcomes can improve care for patients, which as a result will also help ensuring smart spending of healthcare budgets. 
The second part of the day was dedicated to two panel discussions - the first with stakeholders from the Belgian perspective and the second with EU-level policy makers and stakeholders - both discussing how to put this model into practice on a larger scale, the barriers to implementation and how national and EU policy makers could help further this agenda in order to improve patient care while making healthcare systems more financially sustainable. 
UEHP was invited as speaker within the panel on the role of the EU in outcomes-based healthcare, bringing the voice of Private hospitals in Europe at the highest level of discussion. The private sector is a partner of the development of this revolution in healthcare where the patient will be for the first time at the very Center of all decision and actions. We are calling for full transparency at all levels and we are ready to share data in order to give the patient the added value he is looking for and to improve the whole experience of care for all citizens. 
 
UEHP
Launch of Multi-stakeholder Digital Health Roadmap
On 10th the Integrated Care Alliance launched its Multi-Stakeholder Digital Health Roadmap at the European Parliament, kindly hosted by MEP Michel Boni. 
The Integrated Care Alliance was officially launched in June 2016. At this occasion, The ICA Partners published a Call for Action“United towards Integrated Care” that setsout ten recommendations for accelerating the development, uptake and scaling-up of Integrated Care models in Europe. 
Building on the Call for action, the ICA partners joined forces again to elaborate a Multi-Stakeholder Digital Health Roadmap which identifies Integrated Care objectives by 2021, and recommended measures for the implementation. 
The Roadmap was presented at the EP event on 10 October 2018. The event was successful, an opportunity to meet EU Institutions representatives and other key stakeholders, including patients and carers organizations, clinicians, healthcare providers and health IT industry representatives, and openly discuss the way to strengthen and expand integrated, sustainable health and care services across the EU Member States. 
UEHP has been a member of the Integrated Care Alliance form the very beginning!  
We are delighted to work with all the collegues from other associations working in the healthcare sector and to help shape the future of eHealth in Europe! 
More information here: http://www.integratedcarealliance.org/
Picture, from r. to l. : UEHP, MEP Michel Boni, COCIR, EU Commission, European Patients forum, Health Community, ESTRO, VOKA
 
EU
Apply to EU Civic Prize on Chronic Pain - Collection of good practices 2018-2019
The Application period for the second edition of the bi- annual research-project at the European level “EU Civic Prize on Chronic Pain - Collection of good practices” has started. The award is open to any healthcare stakeholder: patients’ associations, health professionals, private and public hospitals, universities, etc.
Your project will be considered for a public European celebration when the prizes are awarded and will represent the recognition of ongoing excellence. A representative from each of the entries that have been short-listed will be invited to this event.
This will foster the formation of a network of good practice practitioners, able to share information, advice and practical help with each other. This the second of a series of prizes –awarded every two years – celebrating progress in the treatment and manage of chronic pain.
Closing date for receiving your submission is 31 December 2018.
The types of good practice to be identified will be classified as follows:
  • Patients’ empowerment
  • Innovation
  • Clinical practices
  • Professional education
 
WORLD
Nobel Prize and Green Hospitals
This year the Nobel Prize in economic sciences rewards Paul Romer and William Nordhaus engaged in “endogenous growth” and climate change implication.
The two major questions of economic development in a liberal model represent a big challenge for the future. First to link continuous economic development to creativity including new ideas by actors, enhancing research and development and protection of intellectual property. Second to respect global warming and climate change implication in a sustainable development project.
How to link economic questions to our specific activity? Ultimately, the healthcare sector is clearly dedicated to one goal, individual well-being: care and cure represent our everyday work, it is the sense of purpose and the professional commitment of all hospital collaborators, from nurses to top management.
At the announcement of the Nobel Prize award, our greatest concern can only be to enforce our implication in sustainable growth. Services to people and innovative organization models can embrace environmental issues. Under pressure from European Member States governments asking for more efficiency with less budget, we try to stabilize an incremental model respecting the future. We have to limit unnecessary consumption of materials, air and liquid pollution, patient and caregiver travels, and carbon emissions. As published in previous UEHP Newsletters, our implication in “green hospitals” is a reality as we continuously strive to promote health by reducing its environmental impact. The engagement of our members is notable, and recommendations of Nobel Prize winners is to be applied in real life.
We are actors of changes, and we are therefore delighted with the result of the Nobel Prize award. We find here a very strong encouragement to maintain this collaborative process on a common objective. We are front runners to claim that private investment includes environmental protection even if restricted budgets are allocated to hospitals. Our responsibility is to accept this challenge and to succeed. The theory in Economic science is more interesting when applied in our everyday life action. The reinforcement of motivation is then strengthened by the application of a positive action recommended by international experts. We are concerned by economics questions, and we are proud to favor applications respecting both the people and the planet.
 
       
 
MEMBER'S CORNER
FRANCE
Quality and relevance of care, a key issue for the private hospital sector... and for patients.
Quality and relevance of care are one of the cornerstones of the Health System Transformation Strategy (STSS) introduced by the French Health Minister Agnès Buzyn.
Private hospitals have long recognized and promoted these concepts. Putting them at the heart of the organization of our system constitutes a genuine paradigm shift and an opportunity to seize.
It is a question of breaking free of an accounting approach to health, disconnected from the field, to better integrate the evolution of the patients ‘needs and the new expectations of health professionals.
The final goal is both simple and fundamental: to enable everyone not just to have access to care but access to relevant care of proven quality.
Quality of care is a key issue which cannot be reduced to a stack of medico-administrative procedures and rules. What is important is the time and energy that teams devote to the patient. It is therefore necessary to take medical quality into account remaining as closely as possible to reality, and to grasp with finesse what constitutes the "value" of a treatment, resulting from a balance between its therapeutic benefit and its human and financial cost.
Only evaluation by "peers", ie specialists in each medical discipline, according to benchmarks developed with all stakeholders, enables the quality of medical practices to be assessed. It is a philosophy of action that the French Federation of Private Hospitals supports and argues with the Ministry and Health Agencies, because it is based on the acknowledgement of the value of skills.
The patient experience is also something that the private hospital sector needs to integrate more into its approaches. Meeting the challenge of quality and relevance of care will only be possible with a patient who is both informed and responsible, co-builder of his care.
We appreciate that, in PLFSS 2019, the share allocated to quality financing increases substantially. But adding coercive measures is ineffective. It is important to keep the positive and encouraging nature of the approach, so that it acts as a real lever for improving practices and consideration for the professionals.
Continuously improving the quality of care is a powerful factor of motivation for professionals, but it is also, and perhaps above all, a question of finally making the service provided to the patient the foundation of all public action in health.
GERMANY
German hospitals in comparison
The PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) indicators 2018 on financial and performance of German hospitals have just been released. This report compares the ratios of public, non-profit and private health care providers each year. For the study, PwC evaluated key figures of 100 German hospitals for the year 2017.
German public hospitals are struggling with high maintenance rates, postponed modernization measures and are performing worse than non-profit and private hospitals in almost all financial metrics.
This is in short the conclusion of the study.
Private hospitals demonstrate efficiency
In average, personnel costs represented 60% of German hospital operating revenue, material costs 27%. Public hospitals scores are in average 8% higher than private hospitals.
Although private hospitals handle less ‟cases” per full-time employee in 2017, the Case-Mix-Index calculating the severity of ‟cases” treated in relation with the amount of economic resources engaged, shows that private hospitals work more efficiently.
The bed occupancy rate reached almost 78% in private hospitals for the year 2017, the best rate.
German private hospitals also achieve the best ranks in the financial analysis part, liquidity, investment rate, indebtedness, etc. and show the highest own capital investment capacity. The EBITDA ratio for private hospitals amounts 8% (public sector -6%).
AUSTRIA
Award Innovation Prize 2018
Three outstanding innovations by private clinics have been rewarded by the Austrian Private Hospitals Federation in the frame of its second Congress in October.
The first prize has been awarded to the Tyrolean private clinic Hochrum for its Surgical Skills Institute (SKI). SKI is a training and research facility, which will be used for advanced training for OR staff, the testing of new implants or instruments as well as research projects.
A video transmission system between the OR, laboratory and lecture halls has also been foreseen.
The second prize awarded the Ebody Ärzte App, an application developed by physicians from the private clinic Maria Hilf in Klagenfurt. This digital tool enables practitioners to access patients medical data, in a safe way and everywhere. Doctors not only keep track of treatment schedules, but also have access to findings and diagnosis.
The third place went to last year's winner The Rehabilitation Center Münster for a therapeutic concept that supports the treatment of multiple sclerosis patients by learning a foreign language.
‟The level of submissions was particularly high this year”, said Dr. Josef Macher, President of the Austrian Private Hospitals Federation. ‟From employee-oriented projects to innovative therapy and nursing concepts to the development of evidence-based studies, the jury of the award has received a wide variety of submissions. The first-class quality that characterizes Austria's private hospitals is significantly influenced by a continuous development and technical progresses - but above all by the initiative and know-how of our employees.”
Picture: Tyrolean private clinic Hochru, 1st prize
PORTUGAL
Portuguese patients say that private hospitals are better
The "Health a Priority" survey carried out under the "3F - Financing, Formula for the Future" project, promoted by the Portuguese Association of Hospital Administrators (APAH), concluded that Portuguese patients have a higher regard, in many aspects, for private hospitals than for public hospitals. The study was developed for APAH by GFK, a market research company.
On a scale of zero to ten, public hospitals score 5.7, while private hospitals have an overall satisfaction score of 7.5.
The respondents evaluated more positively in private hospitals:
  • The waiting time to schedule consultations and / or exams (negative 4.2 score for public hospitals, while private providers score 7.8);
  • The quality of the facilities and the equipment (on a scale of zero to ten, 6 for the public and 7.6 for the private sector);
  • The waiting time regarding consultations and/or exams admission (only 4.4 for the public and 7.6 for the private);
  • Access to more recent and innovative treatments (5.8 for the public and 7.5 for the private);
  • Competence and knowledge of health professionals (Portuguese patients gave a 6.8 score to the public sector and 7.6 to the private sector)
The survey also shows that 3 out of 4 Portuguese patients consider that Health is not a priority for the Government and that 7 out of 10 consider that the investment in health is insufficient.
This report lead to ten recommendations to innovate the Portuguese Financing and Healthcare model, in order to truly place the citizen at the centre of the system.
MAJOR EUROPEAN PRIVATE HOSPITAL GROUPS
ROMANIA
MedLife
What is the place of your hospitals group within the Romanian healthcare system?
MedLife is the largest private healthcare service provider in Romania. In the 22 years of MedLife’s activity, we are delighted to say that it has been through our actions that we have taken medicine to a different level, we have contributed to the accomplishment of important performances in the Romanian healthcare sector and we have proven Romanian patients that they can find, in their home country, the same expertise, technology and methods of treatment as they would find abroad, as well as extraordinary physicians, for whom the patients’ health comes first.
Patients need full solutions, both for their diagnostic and for their treatment. That is why we developed the MedLifeHealthcare System, which includes clinics, laboratories, hospitals, maternity hospitals, centres of excellence, pharmacies and a stem cell bank, and it provides integrated healthcare services under the same roof.
As regards its national coverage, MedLife means: 50 clinics, 20 hyperclinics, 155 sample collection units, 12 pharmacies, 10 hospitals, 10 dentistry centres, 4 maternity hospitals, 33 laboratories, 1 stem cell bank.
The healthcare team comprises 2500 physicians and 1800 nurses, and over 5 million patients have visited us over the years.
What is the shape and the history of your group?
MedLife is a company that has developed organically and by associating with local entrepreneurs, with whom it has managed to build stronger centres. The MedLife Healthcare System did not choose a single niche – laboratory, clinical investigations, hospital, or corporate, but instead it chose all four. Consequently, the MedLife structure is a balanced one.
MedLife is a business built by Romanians, with Romanians, for Romanian medicine.
MedLife has consolidated its nationwide position both with its 20 acquisitions and by developing greenfield locations in key cities of Romania. The most important acquisitions in the past 3 years: DENT ESTET, Anima and Polisano.
The MedLife Healthcare System is the only private healthcare company that comprises a second brand – Sfanta Maria laboratories.
What are your projects / prospects for the coming years?
MedLife will continue to invest in large-scale projects in development, extension, innovation and medical technology, but most of all in digitalisation and online media. At the same time, we have launched actions to see to what extent MedLifecan be present with its own units in neighbouring countries such as Bulgaria, Hungary, or Serbia.
In your opinion, in which way does your group best contribute to public health in your country?
MedLife, through Sfanta Maria brand, is one of the largest private outpatient healthcare service providers having an agreement with the National Health Insurance House (CNAS). Sfanta Maria has a large network of general practitioners and specialist physicians having agreements with CNAS, it is a financially solid company, with a good quality of the medical act.
 
 
AGENDA
 
       
 
20 November
Brussels
UEHP-SHAM Masterclass on “New Generation of Risk Management”
29 November
Brussels
EU Health Summit
8 February 2019
Brusssels
UEHP General Assembly
7 June 2019
Romania
UEHP Council Meeting
 
 
LOOK BACK
IN PICTURES